The Pale Blue Eye

2023 - 1 - 6

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Den of Geek"

The Pale Blue Eye Captures the Heart of Edgar Allan Poe's Mystery (Den of Geek)

Slow and deceptive, The Pale Blue Eye lays out all the clues in an Edgar Allan Poe origin story, and makes you work for them.

Everything is laid out with enough evidence on exhibit to close the case, but enough artistry to pry it further open. Although it is a foregone conclusion in the book, the postscript runs like it was tacked on by a marketing executive. It evokes the eeriness inherent in Poe’s work, the thumbscrew tension of detective examinations, and the romantic despair of Gothic literature. Not merely because of all the terrifying gems to be found in sacred books of profane illumination, but the change in the air. The film is very generous with false conclusions, rash accusations, and atmospheric coincidences. When she and Edgar speak, the film enters the world of melancholy. [Scott Cooper](https://www.denofgeek.com/scott-cooper/)‘s The Pale Blue Eye is a subtle, restrained work of suspense for fans of the slow-burn murder mystery genre. The anticipation is not limited to merely how much or little information we get on the dead cadet, but how little we seem to know about the esteemed constable who opens proceedings with a beer. Rules and regulations are the enemy, and they are both encamped. Daniel Marquis (Toby Jones) proves an uneven medical examiner, and Landor is reluctantly called out of retirement for the case, providing a more thorough post-mortem. Melling’s rapturous reading of the line “ah, books” is as much fun as his recitation of a naughty limerick after downing glass after glass of illegal hooch. Based on Louis Bayard’s 2006 novel, The Pale Blue Eye, the criminal act which incites the plot is instantly riveting.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "ABC News"

Review: 'The Pale Blue Eye' circles its convoluted plot without ... (ABC News)

It's murder at West Point where a young Edgar Allen Poe is a cadet (for real) and the atmosphere is shrouded in mystery and madness. That alone makes "The ...

The great Robert Duvall also shows up as Jean Pepe, an occult expert brought in to investigate a rash of satanic rituals at the Point. There's a hint of suspense when Lea's macho cadet brother Artemus (Harry Lawtey) gets drawn into the case. The time is 1830 and Landor is still mourning the death of his wife and the disappearance of his daughter. What a shame that writer-director Scott Cooper ("Crazy Heart") so utterly fails to build dramatic momentum. To help him break the code of silence among cadets, Landor enlists Poe, who only had a few poems published at the time. There's nothing like a brutal murder or two to connect this pair of obsessives.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Toronto Star"

Christian Bale sang 'silly songs' to his co-star in 'The Pale Blue Eye' (Toronto Star)

Bale plays a detective and Harry Melling a young Edgar Allan Poe in the Netflix film by Bale's close collaborator Scott Cooper.

“It allows you just to really enjoy it and kind of explore.” he’s so keenly observant and that’s the mark of a great actor.” “He was very much trying to make his own way in the world and had a very nomadic existence,” Melling said. In one scene, “we ended up kind of coming to blows a little bit, which just in itself was quite cool. “She was so interesting as a character to unravel and unpack … “The song was extremely useful,” said Melling. So what I’m saying is that the two hours that take place in this film ultimately motivate him to become the writer that he became that we love.” But the Oscar winner preferred to lighten the mood off-screen, and it involved singing a song or two. I’m fairly certain that we see a version of Christian Bale that you don’t see in any other movie.” Based on the novel by Louis Bayard, “The Pale Blue Eye” is set at West Point in 1830 and follows detective Augustus Landor (Bale) who is hired to discreetly investigate the gruesome murder of a cadet. “He’s accustomed in that era to his detective work sometimes leading to beating confessions out of people. But he’s certainly someone who believes himself to be entirely in control of himself and of his life.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "The Conversation UK"

Netflix's The Pale Blue Eye uses a fictional whodunnit to explore the ... (The Conversation UK)

The impressionistic tale of a young Edgar Allan Poe may not be based in fact, but it captures the essence of the young writer.

Yet bringing them together in this way tips The Pale Blue Eye into ludicrous, overlong melodrama. Henry Melling – known to viewers as Dudley Dursey of the The acting, which is mainly excellent, becomes hammy. As more murders ensue, the mystery deepens. Auguste Dupin (whose name Bale’s Augustus Landor partially evokes). The body is found hanging from a tree by the banks of the Hudson. His rib cage has been surgically ripped open and the heart removed. [cinematographer Masanobu Takayanagi’s](https://variety.com/2012/film/news/takayanagi-japanese-transplant-captures-extreme-conditions-1118049919/) evocative palette, where the pale blue cloaks of the West Point cadets contrast with the monochrome winter setting. The specific image of a pale blue eye is evoked by the seductive Lea Marquis’s (Lucy Boynton) eyes and the “piercing look” of detective Augustus Landor (Christian Bale). [crop up repeatedly](https://muse.jhu.edu/article/439628) in Poe’s work: [occult ritual and cryptograms](https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/a-cipher-from-poe-solved/), the border between sanity and insanity, the image of the [beautiful dead woman](https://books.google.co.uk/books?id=090diHhmp40C&printsec=front_cover&redir_esc=) – which Poe notoriously described as “the most poetical topic in the world”. [The Tell-Tale Heart](https://poemuseum.org/the-tell-tale-heart/), the story of a man so disturbed by a lodging house mate’s pale blue “vulture eye” that he kills him and dismembers his body so he can hide it under the floorboards. [Depression and language: analysing Edgar Allan Poe's writings to solve the mystery of his death](https://theconversation.com/depression-and-language-analysing-edgar-allan-poes-writings-to-solve-the-mystery-of-his-death-131421)

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Los Angeles Times"

Netflix's 'Pale Blue Eye': Edgar Allan Poe, cadavers explained (Los Angeles Times)

'A film shouldn't be like an enema,' says writer-director Scott Cooper. Here's how he and frequent collaborator Christian Bale stretched its suspense.

“We wanted it to feel bare, unforgiving and brutal, with a very narrow color palette, almost shooting the film in black and white,” Cooper says. “It was a brutal shoot,” Cooper says. “It made it memorable,” recalls Bale. “Somebody as intense and masculine as Landor is realizing that he’s missed a great deal in assuming that he has time,” Bale says. “He approached him as someone warm, witty and humorous, prone to poetic and romantic flourishes, looking for a connection.” “So lifelike that I would look over at one of the actors looking at his cadaver, and you could see them having an unsettling out-of-body experience. “And Christian is on that ledge with me [to] explore the darker corners of the human psyche.” “When I started to look at his work with more intention, it was a surprise [to discover] how much he has infiltrated culture and my brain without me even knowing that it was him doing so. Cooper has been contemplating the chief questions of “The Pale Blue Eye” since reading it after directing his first film, The gentle yet opinionated loner — not the “Master of the Macabre” just yet — teams up with Landor for the investigation. To become legendary, you have to be a keen, invisible observer and not be a part of the story, which Christian did beautifully.” Transport the audience somewhere, “The Pale Blue Eye” does.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Rolling Stone"

'The Pale Blue Eye' Review: Christian Bale's Netflix Murder-Mystery (Rolling Stone)

Filmmaker Scott Cooper's latest is a gothic thriller about a grizzled detective (Bale) and the young poet investigating a series of brutal killings.

His movies are more coherent for their actorly musculature than for ins and outs and of the stories he tells, and The Pale Blue Eye is no different. The actor starred in Cooper’s Out of the Furnace (2013) and Hostiles (2017). The offense is that it does so in service of a mystery that barely matters. So it’s up to the rest of this dreary set to get our minds going, a job that they only barely get to do, in a movie that does not always seem confident in how and whether it aims to please us. The Pale Blue Eye, written and directed by Scott Cooper and based on the 2003 Louis Bayard novel of the same name, is only ostensibly a movie about a mystery. If he weren’t Edgar Allan Poe, he’d seem like a plant: a character whose strangeness is meant to attract our suspicion, to the benefit of the more obvious crook drifting somewhere in the shadows, pulling the strings. Well, and maybe for the pleasure of his hifalutin drawl, the general Old South essence of his company, which stands out as exotic in the Hudson Valley and has accordingly made him a target among his peers. Really, it’s a movie fixated on the spindly strangeness of the poet somewhat at its center, who’s only recruited into Landor’s company, at first, for the sake of his gothic instincts. And he’s seen enough death, one presumes, that the spookiness of this endeavor, wherein the body count is sure to increase, probably won’t get to him. That means he’s perfect for the job: he has no one and nothing to lose. The coroner and others will eventually discover that the man’s heart has been stolen from his chest and a portion of a note, yet to be deciphered, has been hidden away, clutched in the dead man’s hardened grip. It’s 1830 on the snowy New York campus of the United States Military Academy and a young cadet has been found hanged.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Vulture"

The Pale Blue Eye Is Grisly, Grim, and Surprisingly Moving (Vulture)

Movie review: Christian Bale and Harry Melling star in the new atmospheric Netflix mystery The Pale Blue Eye. Veteran detective Augustus Landor and young ...

This also sets up a challenge for the movie: how to deliver a solution that not only makes sense but also honors the captivating cruelty of the crimes committed. Ultimately, it’s all pretty gripping, not just because of Bale and Melling and the heady atmosphere but because the crimes being investigated are savage on a downright existential level. (Is he the only American in the cast? Robert Duvall (!!!) plays a professor of the occult. We’re dealing with a fundamentally cozy genre, however, and familiarity is allowed and encouraged. (In real life, Poe lasted only a few months at the school.) You also sense, in his mannerisms and speech, that this is a man who will either make his mark on the world or end up dead in a ditch. When Poe visits Landor’s house and admires books that were clearly his daughter’s, we start to understand why the older man has softened around this misfit poet-cadet: The young man reminds him of his lost daughter. This father-son dynamic powers the whole picture and sets up several key moments in the film’s climax. “To remove a man’s heart is to traffic in symbol. Those of us for whom Sherlock Holmes served as a gateway drug into serious literature can testify to this: The Victoriana, the cobblestones and gaslight, all were just as essential as the cases themselves to our fascination, maybe more so. Landor has lost his wife to illness, and his daughter, we’re told, recently ran away from home; he came to these woods to find happiness with his family and wound up alone and embittered. “The heart is a symbol, or it is nothing,” Poe explains.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "TIME"

Breaking Down the Ending of Netflix's <em>The Pale Blue Eye</em> (TIME)

How do Landor and Poe solve the mystery? ( ...

After learning of Ballinger’s involvement from Fry’s diary, Landor killed and mutilated him in the same way to make the murders appear ritualistic. Landor confesses that his daughter, Mattie (Hadley Robinson), didn’t actually run away, but was raped by three assailants on her way home from the academy ball two years earlier and later jumped off a cliff to her death. Lea drugs Poe and, with the help of Artemus and their mother Julia (Gillian Anderson), prepares to cut out his heart and sacrifice him. After finding an officer’s jacket that links Artemus to the scene of Fry’s heart abduction, Landor works out that the Marquis family attempted an occult ritual involving the sacrifice of a human heart to try to prolong Lea’s life—and it worked. “I knew that from the moment I first met you, and here we are.” Mattie came away from the assault holding Fry’s dog tag, leading Landor to seek revenge on Fry following her suicide. Landor manages to pull Poe and Julia to safety, but Lea and Artemus are crushed and killed by falling debris. The diary reveals that Fry and Ballinger were close friends, and, soon after, it’s discovered that their other friend, Cadet Stoddard (Joey Brooks), appears to have run off. The cadet, Leroy Fry (Steven Meier), was hanged and, in an even more disturbing turn of events, had his heart cut out and stolen while his body sat inside the school’s hospital. While The Pale Blue Eye is a work of fiction, the real-life Poe did in fact attend West Point before being Lea suffers from a seizure disorder and has been given only a few months to live. And it’s a doozy of a whodunnit.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Yahoo News Canada"

'The Pale Blue Eye': Why the Christian Bale, Harry Melling murder ... (Yahoo News Canada)

In a grim murder-mystery, Christian Bale's character is hired to find a killer, with Harry Melling as Edgar Allan Poe, The Pale Blue Eye, on Netflix.

Post cover
Image courtesy of "The Review Geek"

The Pale Blue Eye (2023) Ending Explained – Who killed the West ... (The Review Geek)

When a West Point cadet is discovered dead in 1830 and his heart is later carved out of his chest, military leaders of the academy ask Detective Augustus Landor ...

Landor not only killed Fry, but he was summoned to West Point to solve the mystery he created. Poe has all the information he needs to turn Landor in. He left Poe with the note from Fry’s hand (which was assumed to be from Lea). But Poe noticed that the handwriting on the note matches a note that Landor once wrote to him. When Landor rushes in to stop them, Lea knocks over a candle, and fire overtakes the room. Seeing promise in one of the academy’s own, Landor enlists a young cadet for help: the poet Edgar Allan Poe (Henry Melling).

Post cover
Image courtesy of "Den of Geek"

The Pale Blue Eye Explores How Edgar Allan Poe Was Author of the ... (Den of Geek)

Augustus Landor is a fictional creation from Bayard's novel and now Cooper's movie. His last name comes from Poe's short story, “Landor's Cottage.” Originally ...

“The Mystery of Marie Rogêt” is the first murder mystery based on the details of a real crime. In “The Murders in the Rue Morgue,” Dupin calls Vidocq “a good guesser.” In the first Sherlock Holmes story, “A Study in Scarlet” (1887), Holmes similarly dismisses the French detective’s fictional adaptation. It is fun to imagine the writer similarly going along on the case as the unnamed narrator in the short stories. “The Murders in the Rue Morgue” is also the first “locked room” mystery. In the film The Pale Blue Eye, it is young Edgar who eagerly helps the eccentric but brilliant detective probing the academy murders. He has no professional stake in their solution, it is a favor to him to pass the time. Auguste Dupin is the master analyst in Poe’s “The Murders in the Rue Morgue,” “The Mystery of Marie Rogêt,” which was published in three installments in Snowden’s Ladies’ Companion, beginning in late 1842, and “The Purloined Letter,” published in 1844. That generation of readers was among the first to be made to feel actively part of the reported happenings of the day. There is nothing in the room but two bags of gold coins, torn hair, and the blade, still covered in blood. The Edgars, the most prestigious award of the Mystery Writers of America, is named in his honor. A mother and daughter are found dead in the sealed space deemed to be the crime scene. His last name comes from Poe’s short story, “Landor’s Cottage.” Originally published in 1849, it is a descriptive work, without mystery or violence, that works as a contemplative rest stop for the retired detective’s dwelling in The Pale Blue Eye.

Explore the last week