Hailey Bieber is facing backlash for touting "brownie glazed lips" as a trend when the Latina, black and brown communities has been rocking the same look ...
Bieber created her lip look using a brown liner and clear gloss — and while she didn’t claim to have invented the effect, she also didn’t mention the fact that women of color have been rocking the same look for decades. [Justin Bieber’s wife](https://pagesix.com/2022/09/14/justin-and-hailey-bieber-celebrate-their-fourth-wedding-anniversary/) shared her latest makeup look on TikTok with the caption, “ready for all the fall things including brownie glazed lips” — and now, a number of commenters are calling her out for cultural appropriation. [went wild for her “glazed donut” nails](https://pagesix.com/2022/08/25/how-to-do-hailey-biebers-glazed-donut-nails-at-home/) this summer, and her signature skincare trend of the same name even [inspired the launch of her own line](https://pagesix.com/article/hailey-bieber-rhode-skincare-review/), Rhode.
The latest celebrity to cause a stir online is Hailey Bieber, who recently posted a TikTok in which she showed off what she called a "brownie glazed lip.".
Some of Hailey's fans attempted to defend her by pointing out that her mother is Brazilian, and could have been the inspiration for the look. They'll also have to wait to see if she issues any kind of official response to the backlash she has received over questions of appropriation. Some on Twitter pointed out that this appropriation had also led white women to be praised for a technique that many women of color were once criticized for. Eventually, women of color began speaking up, pointing out the absurdity of crediting a white woman with inventing a makeup combination that's been in use for decades. In the original video, which was posted more than a month ago, Hailey is seen applying a brown lip liner and a clear glossy lip treatment from her beauty brand Rhode. The latest celebrity to cause a stir online is
"Ready for all the fall things including brownie glazed lips," Bieber wrote in a caption to a video of her modeling makeup that included dark lip liner and ...
"The ways that young people especially are using outlets like TikTok, for example, to share their stories to share histories," she added. "The problem is around the politics of value -- on whose body is that aesthetic valued, who's able to get value materially in terms of money, in terms of cultural capital?" "It's totally fine for people to play around with body aesthetics and things that inspire them that they see in other cultures," she said. "We're in a society that unevenly attributes value to these body aesthetics depending on the identities of the people." "[Black women and Latinas] are being looked at as lesser than any other woman just because of the way they decide to do their own makeup," Garcia told "Good Morning America." And that's where we get this kind of cultural appropriation."
In a newly released clip for Call Her Daddy, Alex Cooper asks Hailey point-blank if she was “ever with Justin romantically at the same time as [Gomez].”
I guess I needed to find what was that word for me, because I felt so less than in past relationships, and never really felt equal.” Fans immediately speculated the quote was in reference to her relationship with Justin. In one of her most candid interviews about her love life to date, Gomez called her relationships “cursed” in 2021. “I remember I had a moment where I couldn’t believe it, because the first and second day, the reactions were crazy, and I remember I smiled and I was like, ‘That’s why it’s worth it. 4, and fans are [speculating](https://twitter.com/tswiftfiles/status/1574584218067169280?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw%7Ctwcamp%5Etweetembed%7Ctwterm%5E1574584218067169280%7Ctwgr%5E223b5d22934d0cb24f95cd70c005227d8f288656%7Ctwcon%5Es1_&ref_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.newsweek.com%2Fhailey-bieber-accused-damage-control-selena-gomez-documentary-justin-bieber-1746508) that Hailey’s interview is something akin to damage control, or an attempt to [distract from a documentary](https://www.newsweek.com/hailey-bieber-accused-damage-control-selena-gomez-documentary-justin-bieber-1746508) that might not be flattering to Justin and Hailey. “I think most of my experiences in relationships have been cursed,” she [eight years](https://people.com/music/justin-bieber-selena-gomez-relationship-timeline/) starting in 2010. Gomez, to her credit, [bagged](https://www.cosmopolitan.com/entertainment/celebs/a29627851/selena-gomez-dating-history-past-boyfriends/) stars like Zedd, Orlando Bloom, and The Weeknd (and [allegedly Chris Evans](https://www.eonline.com/news/1307429/fans-think-chris-evans-instagram-story-holds-a-clue-about-his-rumored-romance-with-selena-gomez)!); and before rekindling their romance and getting engaged in 2018, Justin and Hailey were first [linked](https://people.com/music/justin-bieber-hailey-bieber-relationship-timeline/) in 2014. (The interview, of course, could also just be promotion for Hailey’s new skincare line Rhode—god knows she might need it with fierce new competitors like [Brad Pitt’s genderless skincare line](https://twitter.com/jehovahgonzalez/status/1572741314554499072)!) But Gomez recently [announced](https://www.instagram.com/reel/CivBiLwJCxL/?utm_source=ig_embed&ig_rid=74597c11-f6fb-4ff2-b5c2-ef59d66a5461) her forthcoming AppleTV+ documentary My Mind & Me, to be released on Nov. [told](https://podcasts.apple.com/us/podcast/hailey-bieber/id1437469957?i=1000499008068) Ashley Graham on her podcast, Pretty Big Deal. In the clip, Cooper asks Hailey point-blank if she was “ever with Justin romantically at the same time as [Gomez].” Hailey responds, “This is so crazy, I’ve literally never talked about this ever. Hailey’s comments in 2020 stoked further speculation: “People don’t know, too, we had been talking for a while before we got back together,” Hailey
For the first time ever, Hailey Bieber addressed the controversy surrounding her marriage to Justin Bieber and his ex Selena Gomez on the 'Call Her Daddy' ...
It closed a chapter and I think it was the best thing that could have happened for him to move on.” Some “Jelena” fans [blamed Hailey](https://www.bustle.com/entertainment/hailey-bieber-asked-social-media-trolls-to-leave-her-alone-tiktok) for her husband’s public breakup with Gomez, whose relationship with Justin lasted intermittently between 2010 until 2018, and have taken to online and IRL harassment of the model. [Hailey Bieber](https://www.bustle.com/style/hailey-bieber-skincare-line-rhode) has addressed [the controversy](https://www.bustle.com/entertainment/hailey-bieber-crying-tiktok-video-met-gala-selena-gomez-chant) surrounding her [marriage to global pop star Justin Bieber](https://www.bustle.com/entertainment/justin-hailey-biebers-relationship-timeline) during the Sept. [Hailey married Justin](https://www.bustle.com/p/are-justin-bieber-hailey-baldwin-getting-married-soon-the-couple-reportedly-took-a-major-step-11915727) in September 2018 soon after the singer called it quits with Gomez. I'm not interested in doing that and I never was.” 28 Call Her Daddy episode, host Cooper asked Hailey if she was “ever with Justin romantically” at the same time as Selena, to which the model promptly responded, “No, not one time.” She continued, “It’s not my character to mess with someone's relationship — I would just never do that. I could kind of hear it, but I didn’t know if that was really going on until I saw the video after.” Addressing rumours that she had become emotional on the Met Gala red carpet, Hailey also clarified that those reports were “not true.” In the episode, Hailey opened up to [host Alex Cooper](https://www.bustle.com/politics/alex-cooper-call-her-daddy-spotify-deal-breakup) about the difficulties of being married to someone with Justin’s enormous public following. Hailey pauses before saying, “Where do I start?” [Speaking in the episode](https://open.spotify.com/episode/0EBTCiYZl535zGYjbC6LXo), Hailey also touched upon the [viral TikTok video](https://www.tiktok.com/@dawnofbizzle/video/7007993935394114821) that captured her putting on sunglasses while walking [the 2021 Met Gala red carpet](https://www.bustle.com/entertainment/hailey-bieber-crying-tiktok-video-met-gala-selena-gomez-chant) after a “Selena, Selena, Selena” chant broke out in front of her, showing the crowd’s allegiance to her husband’s ex-girlfriend [Selena Gomez](https://www.bustle.com/entertainment/selena-gomez-net-worth-songs-movies-tv-shows-rare-makeup-businesses). That just goes to show how out of context things can be seen,” she added. 28 episode of the [Call Her Daddy podcast](https://open.spotify.com/show/7bnjJ7Va1nM07Um4Od55dW?si=67867b61df0845a9). As for the sunglasses, the model also explained that they were “just part of my look.”
Hailey Bieber explained how her husband, Justin Bieber, "closed a chapter" with his ex Selena Gomez before their marriage, breaking down the timeline.
By March of the following year, the reconciled exes [called it quits](https://pagesix.com/2018/03/19/bikini-clad-selena-gomez-surfaces-after-bieber-split/), and he reunited with Hailey in June 2018. You can wish that all you want, but that’s just not the case.” “I don’t want to stir anything up or bring anything up,” she said. “I think it was the best thing that could have happened for him to move on and be engaged and get married and move on with his life in that way,” Hailey explained. “I know for a fact that we were able to get back together was because it was very much completely closed.” The former “Drop the Mic” host said that she “period point blank …
Hailey Bieber has addressed speculation about her relationship with husband Justin Bieber and denied "stealing" him from his ex Selena Gomez.
For the first time, Hailey Bieber addressed questions about her and Justin Bieber's rekindled romance, which came on the heels of him splitting from his ex, ...
"I know for a fact that the reason we were able to get back together was because it was very much completely closed and that is respectful to me." Again, because it was their relationship and I honestly respect that very deeply, but I just know what was going on when we got back together. So, I respect that a lot, but I know that it closed a chapter and I think it was the best thing that could have happened for him to move on and be engaged and get married and like, move on with, with his life in that way." And I had been involved with him since I was 18. (Prior to marrying Hailey in Sept 2018, the "Peaches" singer had an on-and-off relationship with [Selena Gomez](https://www.eonline.com/news/selena_gomez) for almost eight years until the [two split earlier that year](https://www.eonline.com/news/933851/selena-gomez-has-moved-on-from-justin-bieber-and-is-feeling-very-strong)). "I can say period point-blank, I was never with him when he was in a relationship with anybody," Hailey added.
In a teaser for Call Her Daddy, Hailey Bieber acknowledged rumors of an overlap between her and Justin Bieber's relationship and his previous romance with ...
[officially said "I do" in a New York City courthouse](https://www.eonline.com/news/968477/justin-bieber-and-hailey-baldwin-may-be-legally-married). 2018 [official ceremony in front of their loved ones in South Carolina](https://www.eonline.com/news/1010900/justin-bieber-and-hailey-bieber-get-married-again-in-lavish-wedding-ceremony). And from that point on, Hailey and Justin— [who first sparked romance rumors in 2014](https://www.eonline.com/news/950146/justin-bieber-and-hailey-baldwin-s-road-to-engagement)—became inseparable, [with the "Baby" artist getting down on one knee in July 2018](https://www.eonline.com/news/950145/justin-bieber-and-hailey-baldwin-are-engaged-how-he-proposed), [just months after his split from Selena](https://www.eonline.com/news/1085334/selena-gomez-s-lose-you-to-love-me-song-lyrics-decoded). [completely moved on](https://www.eonline.com/news/933851/selena-gomez-has-moved-on-from-justin-bieber-and-is-feeling-very-strong)" from Justin and was "feeling very strong," according to a source. The following year, after settling into married life, Hailey shared insight into her and Justin's rekindled romance. Now that years have passed since the end of #Jelena, Hailey is putting the rumors to rest once and for all during a sit-down for [Call Her Daddy](https://www.instagram.com/p/Ci_a5JqJgIS/). [Ashley Graham](https://www.eonline.com/news/ashley_graham). Well, prior to tying the knot with Hailey, Justin was in an on-off relationship with Selena for about eight years. The stars rekindled their relationship in late 2017 before In response, Hailey told Alex, "This is so crazy I've literally never talked about this ever. As for the skepticism from fans over the years? [Alex Cooper](https://www.eonline.com/news/1299415/after-sealing-a-s60-million-deal-call-her-daddys-alex-cooper-spills-her-career-lessons) noted in a Sept.
Kosas makeup has been used by celebrities like Hailey Bieber, Gwyneth Paltrow, and Naomi Watts, and right now, everything from Kosas is on sale.
$42) [Kosas Color & Light Palette](https://shop-links.co/ciaKoVcShji), $27.20 (orig. $24) [Kosas Tinted Face Oil](https://shop-links.co/ciaKoBSYkTi), $33.60 (orig. $22) [Kosas Weightless Lipstick](https://shop-links.co/ciaKmgjDYKn), $22.40 (orig. $26) [Kosas Air Brow Tinted](https://shop-links.co/ciaKnsNze3E), $16.20 (orig. [Cloud Set Setting Powder](https://shop-links.co/ciaKlAJV9Q4) around her chin, forehead, under-eyes, and nose. [Drew Barrymore](https://people.com/tag/drew-barrymore/) also showed love to Kosas on social media. $28) [Kosas The Big Clean Mascara](https://shop-links.co/ciaKmHB9ZFa), $20.80 (orig. The [Weightless Lipstick](https://shop-links.co/ciaKmgjDYKn) contains botanical oils like jojoba, shea, and rosehip for a buttery-soft feel, and it comes in 11 chic shades, ranging from soft pink and nude to deep purple and brown. [Kosas Revealer Concealer](https://shop-links.co/ciaKk2NfORQ), $22.40 (orig. $28) [Kosas Cloud Set Setting Powder](https://shop-links.co/ciaKlAJV9Q4), $27.20 (orig. $34) [Kosas Wet Lip Oil Gloss](https://shop-links.co/ciaKm7Waasd), $17.60 (orig. [Kosas](https://shop-links.co/ciaKoVcShji), the buzzy beauty brand that bills itself as "clean makeup for skincare freaks."
Hailey Bieber is addressing a suggestions that has long had some of her husband's fans upset.
I would just never do that.” “It’s not my character to mess with someone’s relationship. “They were not in a relationship at that time, but of course there’s a very long history there and it’s not my relationship,” she said.
Hailey Bieber is clearing the air about the fan-fueled notion she stole Justin Bieber from Selena Gomez -- saying that couldn't be further from the truth.
Hailey says no -- adding Selena doesn't have to, as she doesn't owe her anything and that there's no personal beef between them whatsoever. She ends by saying she's spoken with Selena since marrying Justin, and that she respects Selena. Based on what Hailey's saying here, it sounds like there's more to the dynamic (Justin and Selena's, that is) than the public knows, but again ... HB also finishes by noting, she and Justin know the truth ... Justin and Selena were hanging out A LOT in late 2017 and seemed to rekindle their relationship through early 2018, until they abruptly split. even if it looked somewhat quick to the outside world. And, this part will interest Selena fans ... Just to clear up the timeline here ... One more interesting tidbit from her -- she says Justin and her getting together might've actually been the best thing to help him move on from Selena ... especially right before they got married. Hailey Bieber Says She Didn't Steal Justin Bieber Away From Selena Gomez Hailey Bieber I Didn't Steal Justin Away from Selena ...
In her most intimate interview to date, Hailey Bieber addressed her and Justin Bieber's road to marriage and the critics they've faced along the way.
So I think the second you make the decision to do that there's never going back from that and I just don't know that I would ever be willing to like, we've worked very hard. You don't have to like me, but you don't have to say anything either because behind this person that you're looking at on a screen is a person with a brain and a heart and emotions and issues that I face and so do you and so does Alex, and so does every single person in this room. I do think sometimes you need to express it and you need to go to someone who is going to feel safe for you and support you in those thoughts, not make you feel like you're crazy or that you're wrong for feeling dark and deep and heavy." So I've heard some people are in like open relationships and like it works for a time, but I feel like in the end, it always doesn't end up working. But of course there's a very long history there and it's not my relationship, it has nothing to do with me so I respect that a lot, but I know that it closed a chapter and I think it was the best thing that could've happened for him to move on and be engaged and get married and move on with his life in that way." But that was a situation where I know for a fact that it was the right thing for them to close that door, they were not in a relationship at that time. So, yes, I could hear everyone screaming and I think there's a certain part of you that has a numbness of just like...I was really surprised. "When things can get really dark, and you can start having thoughts of, like, it not being worth it anymore or not wanting to be here anymore, which I have had before in the past and coming out of that, I think it's really important...a support system is like the most important thing for sure. When him and I ever started like hooking up or like anything of that sort, he was not ever in a relationship ever, at any point. I think that there are situations where you can still kind of have back and forth with someone but even that was not the situation. "And I guess maybe that just comes from the fact that they wished he had ended up with somebody else. "A lot of the hate and the perpetuation comes from like, 'Oh, you stole [Justin],'" Hailey said of her critics.
“I would never want to get into a relationship and get engaged and be married to them and think in the back of my mind, 'I wonder if that was really, like, ...
The duo called it quits by March of the following year. It is what it is.” [Up Next](https://pagesix.com/2022/09/28/katie-couric-reveals-breast-cancer-diagnosis/) “We know what happened. I respect her a lot, and I think there are no expectations [between us]. “It’s all respect.
The Rhode Skin founder will address claims that she “stole” her husband from Selena Gomez on the popular podcast.
“This is so crazy, I’ve literally never talked about this ever,” she says in the clip. While some were happy for the young duo, fans of Beiber and Gomez alleged that Hailey was to blame for their breakup and have harassed the star ever since. Cooper asks Bieber, “How has being married to someone with that level of fame impacted your identity?” After a brief pause, Bieber laughs and says, “Where do I start?”
Hailey Bieber responded to an extensive line of questioning on 'Call Her Daddy,' clarifying that she was not seeing her now husband, Justin Bieber, ...
Anyway, I now know that Hailey and Justin’s go-to sex position is “definitely not missionary” and that she “really likes doggy style.” Here’s an idea: How about no one asks either of them about sex or Selena Gomez ever again? In April, Hailey posted a [TikTok video](https://www.cosmopolitan.com/entertainment/celebs/a39712177/hailey-bieber-tik-tok-jelena-trolls-leave-me-alone/) asking commenters to “leave me alone at this point.” “Enough time has gone by where it’s valid to leave me alone,” she said, which some interpreted as a reference to her husband’s relationship with Gomez. Some avid Gomez fans have accused Hailey of “stealing” Justin — as recently as 2021, they [camped out at the Met Gala](https://www.bustle.com/entertainment/hailey-bieber-crying-tiktok-video-met-gala-selena-gomez-chant) to chant Gomez’s name when Hailey and Justin arrived on the red carpet. Deleting soon.” The [video](https://www.tiktok.com/@selenagomez/video/7096297624554425646?is_from_webapp=v1&item_id=7096297624554425646&refer=embed&referer_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.elle.com%2Fculture%2Fcelebrities%2Fa39968461%2Fselena-gomez-hailey-bieber-fans-skincare-tiktok-shade-response%2F&referer_url=https%3A%2F%2Fwww.elle.com%2Fculture%2Fcelebrities%2Fa39968461%2Fselena-gomez-hailey-bieber-fans-skincare-tiktok-shade-response%2F&referer_video_id=7096297624554425646) appears to still be up on her TikTok page, but comments are disabled. “Be miserable somewhere else, please.” Sure enough, less than a month later, some of Gomez’s TikTok followers assumed she was [mocking Hailey’s frequent skin-care tutorials](https://www.elle.com/culture/celebrities/a39968461/selena-gomez-hailey-bieber-fans-skincare-tiktok-shade-response/) by posting a silent skin-care video. [“pretty crazy,”](https://www.thecut.com/2020/02/justin-bieber-sex-life-hailey-baldwin.html) [“pretty freaky,”](https://www.thecut.com/2020/01/justin-bieber-weeps-jokes-about-sex-life-at-playback-party.html) [“kind of confusing,”](https://www.thecut.com/2020/05/justin-bieber-says-sex-can-be-kind-of-confusing-during-ama.html) and, most poetically, [“yummy.”](https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8EJ3zbKTWQ8) Hailey has been slightly more oblique but once suggestively confirmed that Justin has [“good hands”](https://www.thecut.com/2019/12/hailey-baldwin-justin-bieber-instagram-comment-hands.html) and said they are a [“married man and woman”](https://www.thecut.com/2020/10/justin-and-hailey-bieber-talk-sex-and-latex-in-vogue-italia.html) who are “comfortable with their sexuality.” In this episode, she added a few details, responding to several truly graphic questions from Cooper that included a “Would you rather?” that I won’t repeat here. [reported](https://www.thecut.com/2018/03/justin-bieber-selena-gomez-relationship-break-church.html). In the season-two premiere of the podcast Call Her Daddy, host Alex Cooper dedicated a large chunk of time to questioning Bieber about the long-standing rumors that she was involved with her now husband, Justin Bieber, while he was still in a relationship with Gomez. Hailey Bieber is attempting to clear the air with regard to Selena Gomez. In this week’s episode, Hailey responded to Cooper’s extensive questioning: “I was never with him when he was in a relationship with anybody.” “I understand how it looks from the outside,” she continued, attempting to confirm once and for all that there’s nothing suspect about the timeline of her marriage, “but they were not in a relationship at that time.” She said she didn’t “want to talk on either one of their behalf” but said about Justin, “I know that it closed a chapter, and I think it was the best thing that could have happened for him to move on and be engaged and get married.” Since then, fans have obsessively picked apart social-media posts, lyrics, and red-carpet appearances for evidence that there’s [lingering drama](https://www.thecut.com/2019/10/unpacking-the-newest-hailey-bieber-selena-gomez-drama.html) surrounding this (admittedly short) relationship timeline. Hailey added that Gomez “doesn’t owe me anything,” emphasizing that “there’s no drama personally” and “it’s all respect, it’s all love.” She also discussed the photos from the Met Gala red carpet in which she appears to be crying as people chant Gomez’s name, saying she had something in her eye and put sunglasses on because they were “part of my look.”